Which receiver would you rather have?

Receiver A:
Height: 6'4"
Weight: 196
40 Yard Dash Time: 4.44
Vertical Leap: 39.5
Broad Jump: 11'04"
3 Cone Drill: 4.33
Receiver A is a tall possession receiver with excellent top end speed which projects him to be a deep threat and redzone weapon at the next level. He is a former track star and world-class long jumper. He has experience playing the X, Y, and Z receiver positions. Receiver A recorded 73 catches for 1,083 yards and 9 touchdowns this past year.

Receiver B:
Height: 6'2"
Weight: 216
40 Yard Dash Time: 4.42
Vertical Leap: 37.0
Broad Jump: 10'08"
3 Cone Drill: DNP
Receiver B is a raw prospect with excellent height/weight/speed ratio. This prospect is still underdeveloped in terms of his route running, but more than makes up for it with his excellent playmaking ability. This receiver has been said to have a "high ceiling". This past season he racked up 46 catches for 778 yards and 5 touchdowns.

A is Hunter? B is Patterson?

Yeah. Hunter lit up the combine.

He's more of a vertical than a WCO receiver. But I wonder if Hunter would be a top 10 pick had he stayed in school the extra year.

Patterson is better with the ball in his hands, but Hunter is a better pure WR (IF...big if....he can regain his confidence).

But 2 thoughts. 1) You don't draft combine drill times. They're an extremely small fraction of the equation. 2) I don't see either as a great fit.

Hunter was an absolute beast in 2010, every bit as explosive as Patterson, in fact he was a much bigger deep threat. He had 415 yards and 7 touchdowns on only 16 catches!!! That's 25 yards per catch. Then he got hurt in 2011 after coming out of the gate strong again with 17 catches for 314 yards and 2 touchdowns in only three games.

When he came back they put Patterson into his old outside position and moved him all over. So he's had to not only adjust to learning new receiver roles this year, but he's also had to come back from a serious injury. In my opinion, this kid is only going to get stronger next year. Whoever gets him is going to get one heck of a weapon.

He's slowly regaining that world class speed he had in 2010. If and when he does, this kid has huge potential going forward. He's a burner on the outside that can beat you with his leaping ability in the redzone. I'd love to see us take a shot on this kid in the 2nd round.

I'll take Tavon Austin over both of them right now.

You do know Hunter lost 20 pounds so he could run a fast 40 right. So that's not his natural playing weight and probably not his real time 40. I would take Patterson but I Like Austin better.

20 LBs? Did someone report that? The man is ~200LBs for the past few years at UT.

FYI

Yea if you watched the combine they said on NFL Network the he had lost weight just to post a fast 40. Now I don't really know if it was 20 pounds he lost but my point is he lost weight to run a fast 40 so he could boost up his draft stock.

interesting. I've liked Tavon all year and I think he's going to have a nice career. I wouldn't waste a high pick on Goodwin though.

I'm not sure 4 Lbs is going to boost anyone bodies 40 time

I agree.

He's listed at 200lbs on the Tennessee Athletics website.
He's listed at 205lbs on ESPN.com
He's listed at 196lbs on the NFL Combine page.
Remember, this kid sat out most of 2011 with a knee injury. It's possible he put on a few lbs and then lost it once he was fully recovered and playing again. Either way, this kid is a world-class athlete with big play ability. If he's there in the 2nd, we should pounce. If you watch this kid's 2010 season you'll see what kind of potential he has for someone in 2013.

Tavon Austin is going to be a slot receiver at the next level, we've already got a good slot receiver in Davone Bess. I'd rather have Ryan Swope than Tavon Austin. Swope is bigger, stronger, and just as fast. Austin's speed isn't going to help him when bigger corners jam him all day long and teams leave a safety high. But a solid route runner like Swope, he'll be able to do damage all day long and you can put him anywhere on the field you want. Not only that but the kid is already well acquainted with our offensive coordinator and quarterback. But don't get me wrong, if Austin is there in the 2nd, the Dolphins are going to have a very difficult decision to make. Austin is a gamebreaker in his own right. I just think Hunter and Swope are better fits.

I'm hoping the Dolphins draft Justin Hunter in the 2nd and Ryan Swope in the 4th. If we did that, I think we would be good going into this year. If we somehow land a big free agent also, we'd be doing great.

Tony, are you going to handle this one, or should I?

I believe Clyde Gates ran a super fast 40 too!

Marquise Goodwin is Clyde Gates 2.0

What is there to handle? Swope is a better fit than Austin. He ran the same 40 yard dash time at the combine despite being four to five inches taller and thirty pounds heavier than Austin. Swope has played under our current offensive coordinator and knows every receiver position in that offense. He'd be able to transition into the new offense very quickly. Once better, in 2011 when he played with our quarterback Ryan Tannehill at A&M, he was Tannehill's go-to-guy. He racked up over 80 catches for over 1,200 yards and 11 touchdowns that season.

While Austin is a good young prospect with blazing speed, he's severly undersized, and the last time we drafted an undersized player from West Virginia he didn't fare too well. While I'm not calling him Pat White, I have to admit his mini-size scares me a bit.

I don't care if Swope ran a 3.7. He's not even close to Austin in terms of speed, quickness, acceleration, etc. There's a reason why one is being touted a top 20 pick and the other a 4th round guy. Swope is Davone Bess...That's it. Maybe a little faster, but I'm not sure he's as quick running underneath routes.

Either way, him and Bess on the same team is just redundant.

Austin is not just a slot WR. He's a weapon similar to Percy Harvin, in that he'll line up at RB, WR, return kicks/punts, and offensively because of his skill set you can get creative with him; much more so than Swope.

I just don't see how the two are comparable. You're of course entitled to your opinion, but I think you're undervaluing what Austin is. I'm not a fan of his at 12, but he's a much more versatile, explosive player than Swope.

The stopwatch would beg to differ with you.

Also, Swope can play every single receiver position. At A&M he was moved all over the field, in fact he played a significant amount of snaps on the outside. There is nothing relegating him to a slot receiver role at 6'0" 205lbs. Not his size or his style of play.

The reason I like him more than Austin is because Austin costs us a 1st or 2nd round pick and Swope would only cost us a late 3rd or mid 4th. Swope is a known commodity to our staff and he's a trusted receiver to our quarterback.

As far as player comparisons, Swope has been compared to Wes Welker and Jordy Nelson, two very good players. I'm sorry but if NFL talent evaluators are comparing him to Welker and Nelson and he's available in the 4th round, why on earth wouldn't you take a shot that he's going to be as good as one of those two guys???

If NFL talent evaluators are comparing him to Welker and Nelson, than why are they also saying he's a 4th round pick?

And the stop watch isn't end all be all. We know how 40 times are. Didn't Jerry Rice run a 4.6 something? Swope's speed does not translate to the field.

he's now being talked about as a 2nd round pick.